Isaiah 8:19 - Exposition

Seek unto them that have familiar spirits. In times of great distress the Israelites seem always to have been tempted to consult those among them who pretended to magic and divination. So Saul in the Philistine war resorted to the witch of Endor ( 1 Samuel 28:7-20 ); Manasseh, threatened by Esar-haddon, "used enchantments, and dealt with familiar spirits and wizards" ( 2 Kings 21:6 ). Israel generally, oppressed by Syria and Assyria, "used divination and enchantments" ( 2 Kings 17:17 ). There was the same inclination now on the part of many Jews. The vexed question of the actual powers possessed by such persons cannot be discussed within the limits of a footnote. It has, moreover, already been treated in the present Commentary, in connection with Le 19:31. Wizards that peep, and that mutter ; rather, that chirp and mutter . Tricks of the ventriloquists, probably, who disguised their voices, and represented that they were the voices of ghosts (comp. Isaiah 29:4 ). The natural speech of some tribes has been compared to the "chirping of birds". Should not a people , etc.? Very abrupt and elliptical Isaiah means to say, "Do not attend to them; but answer, Should not a people," etc.? For the living . This may either mean " instead of the living," or "on behalf of the living seek to the dead?" or, Would not that be plainly preposterous?